Criteria
First of all, I'll make a screen shot to show the layout that I found when I review your site. This is a preview of what an actual review would look like:
SCREEN SHOTSite Name
Date reviewed
By: reviewer
Your website will be review in these areas:
Layout & Design:
(Counts as 20 points of your evaluation)In my mere opinion, the layout is important for your site. By the means of a layout you can express originality. I want to see new things, new styles. I'll review your layout from head to toes, I want to see every possible detail, to give a better evaluation. I'll see if the colours match, if they are nice to the eye, if the font in your header is readable, etc. Furthermore, the layout is my first impression of your site (Apart of the splash, if there is one), so try to make it nice and clean, easy to navigate.
Content:
(Counts as 20 points of your evaluation)Content is the biggest part of your site. Visitors visit your site to eat up all your content, therefore I expect a website with interesting content. Be innovative, creative and add content that other websites don't have. Moreover, if your website concentrates on the blog, make the blog interesting for people to read and enjoy, understandable and with clear grammar.
Coding:
(Counts as 10 points of your evaluation)Coding is very important. I want to see you, as the webmaster, use coding appropriately. I'm not seeking for perfect coding, whatsoever, I just expect to see a clean coding. I'll review your coding, copy and paste some parts, explain the errors and try to suggest some ideas.
Rating
Finally, I'll give you your score. The total points you can get is 50. I'll write a brief summary of the review.
0-10: ?
Your site really needs improvement. Read your review and try to improve. Don't worry!
11-20: ?
It's not that bad, so don't worry! You need a little help, read the review and improve.
21-30: Fine
Your site is not bad, but it isn't good, either. Maybe, try to improve on those aspects I've said on the review.
31-40: Awesome!
Really great website! Some aspects that can be improved easily.
41-50: Excellent!
*claps* This was brilliant. Minor things that can be improved in an instant. Feel proud.